Trading In a Car You Still Owe Money On: How to Read the Purchase Worksheet

Guides / Buyer Guides

Find the replacement price, trade allowance and old lender payout on separate lines. The difference between the trade allowance and the payout tells you whether the old car contributes money to the new purchase or brings debt with it.

Trace one transaction

Suppose the replacement is $29,000, the dealer allows $14,000 for the trade and the old payout is $16,500. The old car has $2,500 of negative equity. Before taxes, fees, cash down or optional items, the amount to cover is $31,500: $29,000 minus $14,000 plus $16,500. If you put $3,000 down, that illustrative subtotal falls to $28,500. Request the dealer’s actual tax calculation separately.

Check the financing section

Compare the amount financed with the worksheet totals. Read the rate, term, payment frequency and total borrowing cost. If a longer term makes the payment look comfortable, check what happens to the total interest and how long the balance may exceed the car’s value. Approval and the terms of carrying old debt depend on the lender.

Before accepting the deal

Ask how long the payout is valid and who sends the funds. Keep a copy of the signed worksheet, finance contract and proof concerning the old loan. If a separate buyer has made an offer for your car, compare both complete transactions, including applicable tax treatment and settlement costs.

Further reading · Financial Consumer Agency of Canada on car financing