An offer for $21,000 can leave you with less than an offer for $20,700. Before choosing, ask each buyer to put the amount payable to you, the conditions and the handover date in writing.
Put both offers on the same footing
Give both buyers the same odometer reading, trim, accident history and photos. Say whether the winter wheels and both keys go with the car. Check whether one figure is an estimate pending inspection and the other is a final offer for the car as described. A buyer who has seen a parking dent has different information from one looking at a clean stock photo.
Compare the money you actually receive
Suppose buyer A offers $21,000 but asks you to spend $450 on a repair first. Buyer B offers $20,700 as the car sits. Before any outstanding loan, A leaves $20,550 and B leaves $20,700. If the same $8,000 lender payout applies to both, your proceeds become $12,550 and $12,700. These are example amounts, not YST quotes.
Ask the question that settles it
“Based on the condition I disclosed, what amount would I receive, who pays my lender, and what could change at handover?” Write down the offer expiry, how many kilometres you may add, whether you need to deliver the car and when payment is released. If a higher figure requires buying another car, ask for the purchase and trade numbers separately before comparing it with a cash sale.