Canadian Black Book vs. a Dealer Offer: Why the Numbers Differ

Guides / Seller Guides

A valuation tool is a starting point. A buyer makes an offer on one particular vehicle. If the figures are far apart, first check whether you are comparing a retail asking price, a trade-in estimate or an offer someone is ready to honour.

Rebuild the estimate with the right car

Check the model year on the permit, the trim, drivetrain, kilometres and postal code. For an SUV offered in front- and all-wheel drive, a single selection can put you in a different comparison group. If the tool asks about condition, read its definition. A recently washed car with a dashboard warning still needs that warning disclosed.

Make the comparison transparent

A listing shows what someone is asking. It rarely tells you what the car sold for or what the seller spent getting it ready. A dealer considering your vehicle will also look at history, current condition and what the inspection establishes. Ask the buyer which facts explain the difference rather than assuming a standard percentage comes off every estimate.

Bring a second point of reference

Save the estimate with its date and inputs. Send two or three nearby listings with matching trim and similar kilometres, plus current photos of your car. Ask for a written offer and its conditions. If the estimate says $19,000 and a buyer offers $17,800, the useful question is whether another buyer will pay more for your actual car on comparable terms.